In Southwest Detroit, a Neighbor Skipped the ER. The Survey Shows Why

Elizabeth Gonzalez's neighbor had a bad virus. By her account, he knew he needed a doctor, and he told her he wasn't going to get one. "He was afraid of ICE being at the emergency room."

Gonzalez is a community organizer with Congress of Communities, which works in Southwest Detroit, a neighborhood where many immigrants live. Her sentence is a small, specific thing, but it describes a calculation being made in a lot of households: not whether care is needed, but whether the waiting room is safe.

A survey from the University of Michigan puts a number near that calculation. Researchers analyzed responses from more than 200 people who were born outside the U.S. and currently live in Detroit, Grand Rapids, Flint and Ypsilanti. More than half said they, or someone they knew, had avoided everyday activities — a doctor's appointment, the school drop-off — out of fear of heightened immigration enforcement.

"We're talking about Michiganders who are avoiding church or avoiding work, or taking a child to school, or avoiding travel, avoiding health care," said Mara Cecilia Ostfeld, a professor at U-M's Ford School of Public Policy and a co-author of the report. Those absences, she said, ripple outward: "This is a public health issue and an education issue and an economic issue."

What can't be postponed

Of all the stops on that list, the emergency room is the one where delay has its own schedule. A missed grocery run can be made up tomorrow; an untreated virus cannot be rescheduled. Gonzalez's neighbor wasn't weighing a copay against convenience. He was weighing a federal officer in a corridor.

The other routes have been re-engineered. Gonzalez described what people in the neighborhood are doing for one another: coworkers organizing ride shares, neighbors delivering groceries, parents setting up video calls between other parents and teachers so a family doesn't have to walk into the school for a meeting. Each of those fixes is a real solution and somebody's unpaid hour. The trip doesn't disappear. It moves onto a neighbor's afternoon.

The effects don't land evenly. Immigrants make up a larger share of several frontline occupations — grocery clerks, custodial workers, childcare providers — so an absence surfaces first in those industries, and then wherever those workers' customers and children happen to be.

Where the numbers get soft

There is a measurement problem built into the findings, and Ostfeld is upfront about it. About 60% of respondents identified as naturalized citizens. Because the survey was anonymous, the researchers did not verify immigration status, and Ostfeld said some people may have called themselves citizens out of fear. She thinks the results likely understate how much fear immigrants in Michigan are feeling as federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers become more visible. "There's a lot of people who are afraid to go to work," she said. "So of course, they're going to be more hesitant to participate in surveys." The fear being measured also suppresses the measuring.

The local politics have their own record of the absence. In January, Detroit City Councilmember Gabriela Santiago-Romero testified before the State Senate Committee on Civil Rights, Judiciary, and Public Safety on a package of bills, all sponsored by Democrats, that would forbid immigration enforcement actions at schools, houses of worship and hospitals, and bar law enforcement from wearing masks in many situations. She said local businesses were struggling to stay afloat because people were afraid to patronize shops, or because employees were afraid to work. "Families are literally starving," she said. Of enforcement officers, she said, "They are manufacturing chaos and fear."

The backdrop is federal. A year into the Trump administration's ramped-up enforcement effort, the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees ICE, said it had deported 605,000 people and that another 1.9 million had "voluntarily self-deported." More than 60,000 people are in immigrant detention, according to a dataset of government figures maintained by Syracuse University; 70% of them have no previous criminal record, and many of those who do have committed minor offenses, including traffic violations.

Gonzalez said Southwest Detroit has been quieter than usual. That is a description of a street, and also of a map — the routes people no longer take, drawn by what has gone missing from them. Beside it sits a second map, the one neighbors are drawing themselves: the ride, the grocery bag, the video call. It works, more or less. It also costs.